December 9, 2022 | 8:04 am
You are here:  / Baseball / Featured / Grading The Trade Deadline In The National League

Grading The Trade Deadline In The National League

As wild as the trading deadline was, it had a scripted feel to it in the National League. In the West the money rich Dodgers went on a shopping spree. The more frugal Giants, made a financially sound choice. The Padres who seem to be on the road to nowhere, continued down that path. In the Central the Cardinals and Pirates made the low cost strategic moves that they have been famous for. While in the Nationals went for more pitching. However it was in New York where the true drama played out.  A player cried, the media lied (maybe I exaggerate), the fans were enraged, but like a movie there was a happy ending.

Let’s break down the happenings in the Senior Circuit.

Washington Nationals:

Grade: C +

Get: Jonathan Papelbon (age 34, RHP)

Give Up: Nick Pivetta (age 22, RHP)

Drew Storen has to be annoyed but the addition of Papelbon strengthens the back of the National’s bullpen. They did not address their offensive woes before the deadline at all. Upper management believes that the return of injured players (Jayson Werth, Ryan Zimmerman, Anthony Rendon & Denard Span) will be a big enough boost.

New York Mets:

Grade: A

Get: Tyler Clippard (age 30, RHP), Juan Uribe (age 36, 3B), Kelly Johnson (age 23, UTL), Yoenis Cespedes (age 29, OF)

Give up: Casey Meiser (age 20 RHP), Robert Whalen (age 21, RHP), John Gant (age 22, RHP), Luis Cessa (age 23, RHP), Michael Fulmer (age 22, RHP)

The Carlos Gomez fiasco made things interesting. However by the deadline the Mets had an improved bench, strengthened their bullpen & added a big bat that they desperately needed. All done while keeping their young core of aces. Not bad, not bad at all. 

Atlanta Braves:

Grade: B –

Get: Robert Whalen (age 21, RHP), John Gant (age 22, RHP), Hector Olivera (age 30, 2B), Paco Rodriguez (age 24, LHP), Zachary Bird (age 21, RHP), Marlins pick (#35 overall)

Give Up: Juan Uribe (age 36, 3B), Kelly Johnson (age 23, UTL),Alex Wood (age 24, LHP), Jose Peraza (age 21, 2B), Jim Johnson (age 32, RHP), Bronson Arroyo (age 38, RHP), Luis Avilan (age 26, LHP)

Interesting to say the least. Trading for the 30 year old Olivera would indicate that management expects big things to happen soon. Of course the loss of Alex Wood seems counter productive to that idea. At the very least you can expect the Braves to be active after the season. There is a game plan here, although I am unsure of what it is.

Miami Marlins:

Grade: C –

Get: Elliot Soto (age 25, SS), Ivan Pineyro (age 23, RHP), Cody Ege (age 24, LHP), Tomas Telis (age 24, C), Kyle Barraclough (age 25, RHP), Kevin Guzman (age 20, RHP), Jeff Brigham (age 23, RHP), Victor Araujo (age 22, RHP)

Give Up: Dan Haren (age 34, RHP), Sam Dyson (age 27, RHP), Matt Latos (age 27, RHP), Mike Morse (age 33, OF), Draft Pick (#34 overall)

The Marlins cleared salary, and received multiple prospects in return. However, none of the prospects appear to have a high ceiling. Miami fans better hope that they make good use of the money they freed up.

Philadelphia Phillies:

Grade: B +

Get: Matt Harrison (age 29 , LHP), Jorge Alfaro (age 22, C), Nick Williams (age 21, OF), Jake Thompson (age 21, RHP), Alec Asher (age 23 , RHP), Jared Eickoff (age 25, RHP), Nick Pivetta (age 22, RHP), Jimmy Cordero (age 23, RHP), Alberto Tirado (age 20, RHP)

Give Up: Cole Hamels (age 31, LHP), Jonathan Papelbon (age 34, LHP), Ben Revere (age 27, OF)

The Phillies weren’t able to pry away that “can’t miss” prospect in exchange for Hamels. However Alfraro, Williams and Thompson all look to have bright futures in the majors. In each trade, the Phils shed salary and enhanced their farm system. No matter what you thought of the teams moves in prior seasons, this is a step in the right direction.

Saint Louis Cardinals:

Grade: B –

Get: Brandon Moss (age 31, 1B/OF), Steve Cishek (age 29, RHP), Jonathan Broxton (age 31, RHP)

Give Up: Rob Kaminsky (age 22, LHP), Kyle Barraclough (age 25, RHP), Malik Collymore (age 20, OF)

Brandon Moss certainly isn’t the sexiest pick up, but he does seem to fit the Cardinals well. He will likely platoon with Mark Reynolds at 1st base, but can also play in the outfield. He is having a down season but historically hits right handed pitching well.

brandon moss

Moss gives the Cardinals depth but isn’t the splash some thought they’d make

Pittsburgh Pirates:

Grade: B –

Get: Joakim Soria (age 31, RHP), J.A. Happ (age 32, LHP), Joe Blanton (age 34, RHP),  Justin Sellers (age 29, SS), Aramis Ramirez (age 37, 3B), Mike Morse (age 33, OF)

Give Up: Jacoby Jones (age 23, SS/OF), Adrien Sampson (age 23, RHP), Player to Be Named Later, Cash, Yhanathon Barrios (age 23, RHP), Jose Tabata (age 26, OF)

The time is now for Pittsburgh, as they acquired multiple veterans for their playoff run. None of the vets they brought in would be considered high impact players. However, on the flip side, they did not trade away a single player who had a future as a Pirate. So any help they get from these new pieces is a plus. 

Chicago Cubs:

Grade: A –

Get: Dan Haren (age 34, RHP), Tommy Hunter (age 29, RHP)

Give Up: Elliot Soto (age 25, SS), Ivan Pineyro (age 23, RHP), Junior Lake (age 25 OF)

Haren seems to have a little bit left in the tank, and fits well in Chicago’s rotation. He is a solid addition for the Cubs as they try to grab a playoff spot. Hunter should help in the bullpen, possibly getting save chances. They did not give up a top tier prospect. Good dealing Cubbies.

Cincinnati Reds:

Grade: B +

Get:Brandon Finnegan (age 22, LHP), Cody Reed (age 22, LHP), John Lamb (age 25, LHP), Adam Duvall (age 26, 1B), Keury Mella (age 22, RHP)

Give Up: Johnny Cueto (age 29, RHP), Mike Leake (age 27, RHP)

It always looks ugly when you trade away your best arms, but it had to be done. Neither Cueto or Leake were likely to resign with the team once the year was over. The Reds got a good deal of talent young arms in return. This is how you turn a bad situation into a positive one.

Milwaukee Brewers:

Grade: C +

Get: Malik Collymore (age 20, OF), Zach Davies (age 22, RHP),Brett Phillips (age 21, OF), Domingo Santana(age 22, OF), Josh Hader (age 21, LHP), Adrien Houser (age 22 RHP)

Give Up: Gerardo Parra (age 28, OF), Jonathan Broxton (age 31, RHP), Carlos Gomez (age 29, OF), Mike Fiers (age 30, RHP)

The Brewers, with their playoff dreams long gone, decide to move some of their veteran talent. The deals for Broxton and Parra didn’t give them much return. However the prospects brought back for dealing Gomez and Fiers were top notch. If Phillips and/or Santana reach their potential this deal could be considered a clear win by the Brew Crew.

Los Angeles Dodgers:

Grade: B

Get: Alex Wood (age 24, LHP), Matt Latos (age 27, RHP) Jose Peraza (age 21, 2B), Jim Johnson (age 32, RHP), Bronson Arroyo (age 38, RHP), Luis Avilan (age 26, LHP), Jose Tabata (age 26, OF)

Give Up: Hector Olivera (age 30, 2B), Paco Rodriguez (age 24, LHP), Zachary Bird (age 21, RHP), Kevin Guzman (age 20, RHP), Jeff Brigham (age 23, RHP), Victor Araujo (age 22, RHP)

Clearly talent wise, this deal would be “A” status.  My question is this: are the Dodgers truly impervious financially? They continue to throw money around without caution. It would seem that this strategy will eventually catch up to them. Maybe as soon as this off-season when Zack Greinke is likely to opt out of his contract. With that said, the Dodgers no longer have to afraid when it’s time for the back end of their rotation to pitch.

San Francisco Giants:

Grade: B

Get: Mike Leake (age 27, RHP)

Give Up: Adam Duvall (age 26, 1B), Keury Mella (age 22, RHP)

It is possible that Mella eventually makes this deal look bad for the Giants. Still, San Francisco got the rotation arm they needed for this years playoff run. A savvy move, just the type that the Giants have become famous for.


Leake should help a staff that has battled injury all season

Arizona Diamondbacks:

Grade: D

Get: Player to be Named Later

Give Up: J.C. Ramirez

No comment because not much was done.

San Diego Padres:

Grade: F

Get: Marc Rzepczynski (age 29, LHP)

Give Up: Abraham Almonte (age 26, OF)

The Padres made a big splash during this past off season. Those deals didn’t work out like expected. Sometimes bold moves don’t work out. However this trade deadline would’ve been a great time to reverse course and replenish their farm system. Instead they sat on their hands. Justin Upton should have been dealt.

Colorado Rockies:

Grade: C –

Get:Jose Reyes (age 32, SS), Miguel Castro (age 20, RHP), Jeff Hoffman (age 22 RHP), Jesus Tinolo (age 20 RHP),

Give Up: Troy Tulowitski (age 30, SS), Latroy Hawkins (age 42, RHP)

Moving your franchise player always hurts and this was no exception. While the Rockies did get solid a return, the package is not the mega-haul one would expect for the best shortstop in baseball.

Social Media